Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Social Democracy and Health Care, and What About the Indigenous


The social democracy perspective believes in many attributes, a few of them being: the common or collective good is primary, the nation-state’s role is to regulate the economy a belief in levelling out society’s social and economic inequalities, and protect the environment, and also equality of condition as a social goal (Mullaly, 2007, p.123). All these aspects of social democracy contribute to Canada’s health care policy in that it is universal, and free. In this way, Canadian health care policy emphasises that health care is for the common good of society, and universal health care gives everyone a equal chance to have health care services and an equality of condition. Despite these efforts at equality, there should be more done to help Indigenous people especially, because of their declining health compared to the majority of the Canadian population.
A health survey was done in randomly selected reserves to gather data on the health of Indigenous people in Canada. The results of the survey concluded that, on average, Indigenous people’s health quality is much less then the average Canadians. The author states that, “the rates of chronic health conditions were generally higher among First Nations adults compared with the NPHS-O [National Population Health Survey – Ottawa]” (Faries et al., 2003, p.170). With Indigenous people’s health declining, more must be done to help Indigenous people and their health with more access to programs, funding, and institutions.
            In conclusion, although health care in Canada is universal and free, Indigenous people’s health is not in the same condition as the average Canadian. Indigenous people do not have equal living and quality of life conditions, and something must be done to correct the situation Indigenous people are facing.  


Desapriya, E. (2010). First Nations Health Data. Canadian Medical Association. Journal, 281. Retrieved from http://sfxhosted.exlibrisgroup.com/umanitoba?sid=sfxit.com:citation&id=doi:10.1503/cmaj.110-2028
MacMillian, H.L., Walsh, C.A., Jamieson, E., Wong, M., Faries, E.J., McCue, H., et al. (2003). The health of ontario first nations people. Canadian Journal of Public Health, 94(3), 168-168-72. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/220177307?accountid=14569
Mullaly, B. (2007). The New Structural Social Work. Canada: Oxford University Press.

-Kerri




5 comments:

  1. Well done! I completely agree with you that healthcare in Canada needs to address the issues of Indigenous peoples on reserves, however I think it would also be prudent to link the rates of chronic health conditions among First Nations people to their living conditions. In examining their living conditions it may become more evident as to why their health is suffering; I think more should be done with regards to improving living conditions, in order to improve the health situation.

    Kirsten

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am very suprised there are not many health services to help indigenous people directly. We seem to still live in a society where the government is trying to push them aside. Like you said their living conditions can be a factor but not only physical health but mental health is a big one which is still brought on by the cycle that started with colonization and residential school trauma, discrimination, and the loss of their culture. It is very sad and I hope we can help bring them back to their roots and move past this.

    Brittany

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very interesting post! Interesting to know that Canada's health care system is not as great as everyone thinks it to be. Especially for the founders of the country you would think it would benefit them more than anyone else. I agree with you that things need to be done in order to help the Indigenous people of Canada that are facing these health problems. More health programs should be available for them.

    - Marcia M

    ReplyDelete
  4. Good post. I know that there are many leaders in the north who are not pleased with the current state of health services in northern Manitoba. I recall reading news articles this past year explaining that First nation’s leaders were upset with the 2011 Manitoba Budget. I know many are also upset, because there are not enough doctors and nurses in the north. The nurses are stressed or overworked. If I can recall I believe that northern leaders are demanding an inquiry into health services, because there was no mention of it in this year’s past 2011 Manitoba budget. Interesting…

    I am glad you brought this issue up.

    Dara

    ReplyDelete
  5. Good post. I know you mentioned that the surveys were done on reserves for the health of people living there. Does this hold true for people who are not on reserves?
    Leah

    ReplyDelete